Constructive dismissal can be a costly and stressful experience for any UK employer. But what exactly is it, and how can you prevent it from happening?

Understanding Constructive Dismissal

In simple terms, constructive dismissal occurs when an employee resigns because of their employer’s conduct. The employer’s behaviour essentially breaches the employee’s contract of employment, leaving the employee feeling they have no choice but to leave. This is distinct from an outright firing.

Key Elements of a Constructive Dismissal Claim:

  • Fundamental Breach of Contract: The employer must have seriously violated a significant term in the employment contract. This could be not paying wages, demotion without cause, creating a hostile work environment, or making significant changes to working conditions without agreement.
  • Resignation in Response: The employee must resign as a direct result of the employer’s actions. They cannot continue working and later claim constructive dismissal.
  • No Acceptance of Breach: The employee must not have done anything to indicate they accepted the breach of contract. This could include continuing to work for a significant period after the breach occurred.

Why Constructive Dismissal Matters

If an employee successfully claims constructive dismissal, they can bring a claim for unfair dismissal to an employment tribunal. This can lead to significant financial compensation and reputational damage for the employer.

Preventing Constructive Dismissal

  1. Know Your Contracts: Ensure employment contracts are clear, up-to-date, and comply with UK employment law.
  2. Open Communication: Foster a workplace culture of open communication. Encourage employees to raise concerns before they escalate.
  3. Fairness and Consistency: Treat employees fairly and consistently. Avoid favouritism and ensure any disciplinary actions or changes to working conditions are handled professionally and in accordance with established procedures.
  4. Timely Resolution: Address grievances and complaints promptly and thoroughly. Follow formal grievance procedures and document all steps.
  5. Seek Advice: If a situation becomes complex, seek professional advice from an HR consultant.

What to Do if Faced with a Constructive Dismissal Claim

  1. Don’t Panic: Remain calm and gather all relevant documentation, including the employee’s contract, performance reviews, and any communication related to the alleged breach.
  2. Seek Advice: Contact an HR consultant or employment expert immediately. They can advise you on the strength of the claim and the best course of action.
  3. Early Conciliation: Participate in ACAS early conciliation. This is a mandatory step before taking a claim to the employment tribunal. It can help resolve disputes without the need for legal action.
  4. Prepare for Tribunal: If the claim proceeds to tribunal, your lawyer will help you prepare your defence. This will involve presenting evidence and arguments to show you did not breach the employee’s contract or that the breach was not fundamental.

In Conclusion

Constructive dismissal can be a challenging issue for employers, but by understanding the law, fostering a positive workplace, and acting promptly when issues arise, you can significantly reduce the risk of a claim. Remember, prevention is always better than cure.

Need HR Help?

At The HR Consultants we provide HR without the blah blah blah. Our team of HR experts will support your people problems, however big or small, so get in touch for a no obligation chat